When Pencil Met Gel Sharpenable Multi-Use Longwear Eyeliner Pencil - Rich Brown - Transfer-Proof - High Performance Liner

I was looking for an Urban Decay dupe for less and this is it! It glides on so easily and smoothly! Great color. I got the chocolate color. It lasts all day. I purchased it in August and I have about half of it left now in December. I’m reordering it with some Christmas money I have now, but I won’t need to use the refill for another couple of months.

I love this eyeliner but why don't they try to sell the sharpener? I almost threw mine away because I thought it was finished! It did not come with instructions or to to sharpen as needed or anything. They are missing huge market sales at 13.00 a pop. I wonder how many people are as clueless as I was??? I love this eyeliner and I want to buy ALL the colors now...but I almost wrote of the entire line based on my experience thinking I had to throw it away so quickly! Haha I'm so glad I looked at the description online again before I did. My sharpener arrives tomorrow! Hooray! It truly feels like a gel pen.. I'm thinking no way this is a pencil to sharpen .. it's that different from normal pencils. Try it! Goes on soooooooo easy on my mature eyes.

Suprisingly good eyeliner! Glides on, has staying power, and good color pigmentation. I usually either use eyeshadow on my eyeliner to set it, or set it with a setting spray (or both), and I have not experienced smudging or flaking. My only complaint is that it does not sharpen to a fine point even using the Julep sharpener, but that's not a deal breaker for me.

Nice soft color. The gel glides on smoothly. I don’t think it lasts all day but it is a good liner.

Excellent liner. Stays putand does not bleed. I use it for my water lineand after 8 hours of wear it was still in place. Considering I've spent far more on liners that did not work at all, I would say this is the best I've tried.

The green shade of this eyeliner is absolutely gorgeous — rich, vibrant, and flattering. Unfortunately, the formula didn’t hold up well and melted within a couple of hours, leaving me with smudges under my eyes. ✅ Pros: Stunning, unique green color Applies smoothly without tugging ❌ Cons: Smudges easily and transfers to lower lids Doesn’t last long in warm weather or humid conditions Details & Tips: This could work for short wear or photos, but it’s not reliable for all-day use unless you set it heavily with powder or eyeshadow. Sadly, it just didn’t work for me in real-world wear.

This pencil glides on smooth and lasts all day! It is smudge resistant and is deeply pigmented. A little goes a long way! Great value!

Very smooth when goin on, its waterproof, - you need to use makeup remover to get all off, blendable/smudgeable but need to be quick about it or it will set. Quality product. Disappointed in that the sharpener doesn't come with it as shown in photo....better yet make it self sharpening - hence the 4 stars. Bought the navy and color is as shown.