World's Best Shirt Stays for Men Police and Military-Heavy Duty-Made in USA (Original Style Select Series Garters/Keepers)

Prior to reviewing the item, just a bit of info to help you assign the proper weight to a review prior to your decision to make a purchase or not, and I purchase the reviewed items with my money, just FYI so you know I have no conflict of interest in my review I wear these style shirt stays at least 5 days of the week for approximately 12 hours of the day during which I may be sitting, standing, driving, kneeling down, etc. so I need a stay that has a quality clasp and good quality elastic to keep up. I have tried nearly every version of shirt/sock elastic stay you will find for purchase on Amazon and will review those that stand out as mediocre, poor, or excellent. If you have not used these before, they are simply made to keep your shirt nice and neatly tucked in, while they also keep your socks pulled up, performing two functions that help keep you looking well-kempt from the time you finish dressing through the longest days. Take note, one measure is the clamping force of the clasps, but contrary to what you might think, more pressure alone does not make for a superior design. While more force would keep them in place, personally, I do not want holes in my clothing which is what too much pressure from the clasp will, and has done, to shirts and socks. Assuming you adjust the stay to the appropriate length, a the clasps success, or failure (which include damaging your clothes) depends on the combination of clamping force and the clasps retention teeth. The tooth design and material greatly affects the ability of the stay to function as expected. These measures plus the overall durability is what I base my reviews of shirt stays on. Now on to the review......I have had these for 2 years so I believe my review provides comes with sufficient use to be helpful and accurate.Despite many models costing half as much appear identical, looks can be deceiving. First the clasps are well designed to effectively hold tight to your clothes, and some cheaper models apply the same or more clamping force. That may sound like a good thing, but it is an example of the functional difference between cheap knock-offs and these because they all have little teeth in the clasp, and the cheaper versions will actually damage your clothes applying excessive pressure. Next, the length adjusting sliders stay in place. May seem silly having to make this point, but I have compared inconspicuous details on the plastic adjusters, and they are not all the same. These stays have little extra teeth locking them in place tighter when force is placed on them from the stretch of the elastic. Compared to the cheaper stays, you find that the adjusting buckle does not have the little extra teeth that give the high quality stays additional friction to stay in place. Finally, the elastic used in these is superior to that used in the cheap versions. I believe that as all elastic warms up, the rubber woven in it becomes more "stretchy" but the higher quality elastic in these shirt stays seem to remain more taut. I'm not an elastic expert, but assume these use a material with higher density of rubber strands that provide the elastic. This translates into increased durability as well. Keep in mind all elastic material wears out eventually as the rubber breaks down or snaps, but these have maintained their elasticity over the 2 years of use better than any other shirt stays I have put through their paces.Yeah, this is a lengthy review for what seems like an insignificant accessory in your wardrobe, but if they do not stay put, you will soon realize how aggravating it is to repeatedly have to reattach them while fully dressed. I hope you find this informative and helpful when selecting a quality model shirt stay.

I was a Marine for 8 years and now have been a police officer for the last ten years. I always used those cheap shirt stays with the plastic knob fasteners. They were adequate and there weren't many options. I saw these and decided to give them a try. Worth every penny spent. I waited a few months before writing the review. Thats about the time my other shirt stays would start getting loose. I'll simply say that once fastened they won't pop off in the middle, or even end, of your shift. The elastic is thick and durable. Best shirt stays on the market.

They work exactly as described. They are very effective at keeping a dress shirt looking sharp. I don't find them as comfortable as not wearing them but it's not an issue for me. That could be an issue for others.

They work well, but make sores, where they contact my skin. I sprayed them with Plasti-dip, to insulate the surfaces that touch my legs and thighs, from the nickel coating. If you can’t keep your shirt tail tucked, there is none better. If you are allergic to nickel, paint them with plasti-dip, let it dry, and you’ll be fine.In the photo, the one on the left is as they come, the one on the right is painted with 2 coats of plasti-dip.I cannot explain why or how, but in the past, the metal would corrode with my body chemistry while making my legs hurt. I would put tape on them, but it would come off. Plasti-dip is the best way to counteract this affect, that I’ve found.They make it tricky to use the restroom. Typically. I’ll disconnect the rear two, from my sock, then clip them together, in front of my abdomen.My shirt stays in place, making my uniform look neat, and proper, not sloppy, from shirt tails sticking out.

I've been buying these for a few years now (typically have to buy a new pair every year because eventually the elastic just stretches to the point it doesn't do much anymore)The last pair I purchased, one of the clips was on backwards, not a huge deal but a slight annoyance nonetheless.I've tried the Y Style and the Original Style and I prefer the original style because the Y style tends to pull on the bottom button of my shirts because it's essentially pulling both sides away from the button. I've had a few buttons snap off due to that, although I wear my shirts a bit snug so that could contribute to the problem.Sometimes if you wear shorter socks, the clips can dig into your legs causing itchiness and red marks after 4-6 hours of use and I assume this is because it's just tighter (due to the shorter socks) so just keep that in mind. These can also cause some damage to your socks if they're not good quality socks after prolonged use. I typically take the buckles to their longest size (I'm 6'2" and slim).I would rate these 5 stars if I didn't have to buy a new pair every year. Granted they're only $22 but it's still a bit frustrating that after some time they get looser and looser with time. I think if they just made these a bit longer so I could actually adjust it to the proper length instead of just "tolerating" it, would be better.

I have repurposed these shirt stays to use as to keep light jackets and sweaters from gaping open. I cut off the existing elastic and sewed a decorative cover with a bead in the middle. Love them!

These straps work great. The only downside is that they're a little annoying to wear for long periods of time.